well, i'd say "the ring", although i have watched it so many times that it has no effect on me anymore.
The Ring wasn't bad. I generally don't get scared by unbelievable crap.. like Freddy vs Jason or any of that. I actually got really freaked out by Dexter.. serial killers, man.
Saw movies are just full of gore nothing that actually scares anyone. btw to the user who said "Cloverfield was horrible" shame on yuu. It was a very good movie. ^_^ Scariest movie I've seen is.. probably the Exorcist.. that girl... ugh.
Forrest Gump. It's just so scary how bad of a movie it is. No, but really, Jacob's Ladder creeped me out.
Ever since I was like, 13, scary movies just stopped being scary. Anything that involves a monster/alien/stuff like that, is just so stupid that it is impossible to get scared. The movies that still give me the creeps sometimes, are ones in which some wierd psycho is the scary guy (Like in "The Signal"). But even then it isn't really scary. Only reason I get scared from a movie nowadays is when something jumps up at the screen (comon, it's impossible not to be frightened xD) And Cloverfield was a fun movie, but I wouldn't even call it a "Horror" movie, more like "Action" or somethin...I dunno.
I don't remember myself being scared by a "scary" movie, but if you want to watch something disgusting, with gore, I'd recomment August Underground and Hostel(not a bad plot in this one, too) if you're into psychological type of horror, it's Eraserhead all the way. Begotten is okay too, but only the beginning isn't entirely boring with slow motion.
That's exactly how I feel - I really don't get scared anymore.. I like watching psychological movies though (like The Others) which actually "scared" me a bit because it had such an unexpected twist to it.. but yeah, I couldn't really point out the scariest movie - I dont think that Saw and Chainsaw Massacre were scary, they were just gross :b If I had to pick one though, I'd probably say Excorsist.
Chainsaw Massacre I wasn't scare of the movie, just scared cause my cousin said they did things they seen in their sleep 0_o
When I was younger, The Village scared me so much, yet now I watch it and I think it's clever x3 Dawn of the Dead and Final Destination movies make me uneasy... FD has stupid cheap gore, but the concept scares me. EDIT: I grave dug again! *frown* Im no good at this... *sigh*