Rate my siggies <3

Yeah, I'm trying to learn to use photoshop.



These siggies are pretty much my first attempts at actually making something out of a render in photoshop :3




Images:

Spoiler

Spoiler

Rate them <3

 

First one -----------> 7/10
Second one -----------> epic fail, 5/10

Still pretty good for a newbie though.

 

The first one is okay, but it'd be better without the black border of the car.
And the second one ain't really great =p

 

I don't get why you always have to act rude towards people with "lesser" graphics talent. If someone told me my first signature was epic fail I wouldn't really want to continue.

Anyways, for a start they are really really good. Especially the first one. I'd suggest looking up some tutorials either on this site (there's a few amazing ones!) or on Photoshop help sites.

 

Thanks for the reviews




Yeah, I'm going to have a look at some guides.. 'cause I really had no idea what I was doing - I just grabbed a render and screwed with it :/

 

1St= 6.5
2St= 3.0

Sorry but u should work more on it =(

 

The frist: 6/10
The second: 4/10
I don't like the effects ....

 

The first is decent the second isn't so great but it's not that difficult to get better at so keep making them!

 

I think you could experiment with blending the top colour and the bottom colour in the first one to make it more natural.

 

1 mil/10 for both.

 

i liked the second one , if only you could make the colours true ( as in not cartoonish). first one looked too amatuer ..

sorry for the criticism!