Although I don't know for sure what the prices on every rare item you can get are, I do know Flask of Rainbow Fountain Water, Mysterious Swirly Potion, and an Irritable Genie are all pretty ets items that sell for over 200k each (MSP may be less now though)
Were you asking what was the best prize we personnally got ? If so, I think it's a Bag of Broken Neopoints. I never remember that daily, so the fishing level of my pets are never high.
just some random fish? how sad... do you visit there everyday? you get better stuff if you have higher fishing skills
You can do the UW fishing once every 30 minutes. I had a guide on the items you can get... Gimme some time, I'll find and I'll post it again
the best itme you can get is a mysterious swirly potion, which changes your pet to a random color i think it sells for around 1 mil
Yeah it's Flask of Rainbow Fountain Water, and has actually inflated to around 2 million neopoints now that a lot of the richies are buying them up to get a robot pet or some other rare colour. My friend spent 50 million to get his pet robot with multiple flasks. It's crazy...
Woops, must have misread your question then. Anyways, the best thing I have ever gotten was a pike pike back when they were around 110k.
I'm way too lazy to go every day. Mine are like Level12? Summut like that.. I've generally got shite; like random fish and bits of shoes. Fishing is the new old Tombola
I actually forgot about that daily for a while. The only pet I've been taking fishing is a level 60-something and all I've gotten is seaweed, shoes, and the occasional fish. I've never even caught a broken NP bag.
I am on level 330 and waiting still for the Flask of Rainbow Fountain Water or something worth more than 2 np
Well, putting no effort in to gain crap items that you have to dispose of manually might actually be a bad thing